statements see whether they are Caelestius’ or not. I, however, have never held them, and I declare anathema those who hold them.”42 How could he never have held them, if he had produced this book earlier? Or how does he declare anathema those who hold them, if he produced this book afterward? 24. Perhaps he will reply that he said in that passage that we should “by doing God’s will merit divine grace,” in the sense that additional grace is given to those who believe and live good lives so that